Paragone

Definition

The Paragone was a structured Renaissance debate about which art form held the highest intellectual and creative status. The primary contest was painting versus sculpture, but poetry, music, and architecture also featured. The debate mattered because it determined whether practitioners of these arts were considered artisans (mere craftsmen) or learned men — whether painting was a liberal art or a mechanical art.

Leonardo's contribution, collected in the opening sections of the Codex Urbinas (the basis for the printed Treatise on Painting), runs to dozens of pages. His arguments are simultaneously philosophical, practical, and polemical. He compares the sensory immediacy of painting to the abstract nature of poetry, the physical effort of sculpture to the intellectual subtlety of painting, and the permanence of painted works to the temporal experience of music.

Leonardo's Core Arguments

• Painting vs. Poetry: Poetry reaches the mind through the ear; painting reaches it instantaneously through the eye — "the most rapid of all the senses." A poem describing a beautiful landscape takes time to read; the painting delivers it in a single glance.
• Painting vs. Sculpture: Sculpture is manual labour — the sculptor sweats, gets covered in marble dust, and uses brute force. Painting requires pure mental invention. "The painter sits at his ease before his work, well dressed, and moves a light brush dipped in delicate color."
• Painting as Science: The painter must understand perspective, anatomy, optics, proportion, geology, botany — making painting the highest synthesis of knowledge.

Leonardo's Own Words

"Painting is poetry that is seen rather than felt, and poetry is painting that is felt rather than seen." — Paragone, §23

"The painter strives and competes with nature." — Treatise on Painting, §11

Used In

• Notebooks: Art of Painting — Paragone arguments appear throughout
• Quote Explorer — multiple Paragone quotes collected

Related Terms